Shop Our Latest Catalog

Click below to flick through out latest catalog. 

All Star Cards opened in Overland Park, Kansas back in 1991. We went from a small retail store, to hosting multiple retail locations by the mid-1990’s. By 1998 we had developed the mail order side of the business which allowed us to grow nationally. In 2001, we devoted the entire business model to mail order and began the monthly version of the All Star Cards catalog.

Recently Added

All Star Cards

If you have any questions about how we operate, what we buy & sell, how our auctions work or anything else, just pick up the phone and call us. Our advice and the phone call are free. (Unfortunately, you do have to pay for the cards!) Our staff, Charlie, Michelle and Craig have over 50 years of combined experience in the sports collectibles industry. We have been a PSA authorized dealer for the last 18 years as well as regional correspondents for Beckett price guide and long time advertisers in Sports Collector’s Digest, Beckett and PSA’s Sports Market Report. We take pride in helping our customers in a friendly, respectful and ethical way as we try to build long term relationships with our clients.

Shop Our Card Selection

Happy Customers

Request a Catalog