BUYING LIST

Turn your cards into cash!

Sell your cards easily with transparent pricing and fast payments. No auctions, no fees, no delays.

If you’ve sold on eBay, you know it can be slow and stressful. 

With eBay auctions, you never know what your card will actually sell for. With eBay fixed-price listings, your card may sit for months without selling.

And even when it does sell, the process isn’t over…

  • eBay takes 13% in fees
  • Buyers may not pay — or may pay slowly
  • You wait in line at the post office to ship your card
  • Your card goes to the eBay authenticator (4 days), gets authenticated (another 4 days), ships to the buyer (another 4 days), and only then does eBay verify delivery and release your funds
  • And after that, the buyer can still ask you for a refund!

Selling to us is simple and secure.

Our buying process is fast, secure, and straightforward:

  • A posted price you can rely on receiving
  • PayPal funds within 24 hours, or
  • A check mailed within 24 hours of receiving your cards, or
  • Instant store credit toward cards you want to purchase

To sell your cards, contact us at (800) 932-3667.

Catalog Request Form
Request a copy of our free catalog!
Newsletter Signup Form
Signup for the All Star Cards Inc free newsletter and be the first one to know about new inventory, updates, and promotions! You can opt out at any time.
The All Star Cards Inc newsletter will be sent to the email address you provide. Your email will not be shared with others or made public.
Contact Form

Request a Catalog